Close Menu
GeekBlog

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    What's Hot

    Primatologist Jane Goodall, 91, dies during U.S. tour

    October 2, 2025

    Apple shifts from cheaper Vision Pro to accelerate AI smart glasses

    October 2, 2025

    U.S. Congress deadlocked as shutdown begins; 750,000 workers face furloughs

    October 2, 2025
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Threads
    GeekBlog
    • Home
    • Mobile
    • Reviews
    • Tech News
    • Deals & Offers
    • Gadgets
      • How-To Guides
    • Laptops & PCs
      • AI & Software
    • Blog
    Facebook
    GeekBlog
    Home»Tech News»Tribunal hears Microsoft case on whether second hand Office and Windows license trading is unlawful
    Tech News

    Tribunal hears Microsoft case on whether second hand Office and Windows license trading is unlawful

    Michael ComaousBy Michael ComaousSeptember 12, 20252 Mins Read
    Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email Copy Link
    Issy les Moulineaux, France - January 2020 : Microsoft France headquarters entrance in Issy les Moulineaux near Paris
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email Copy Link

    • Microsoft continues tribunal fight over legality of reselling Office and Windows licenses
    • ValueLicensing claims Microsoft restricted resale market and seeks £270 million in damages
    • Outcome could reshape the future of Europe’s second-hand software industry

    Microsoft’s long-running dispute with ValueLicensing, a UK reseller of pre-owned licenses for products like Windows and Office, returns to the Competition Appeal Tribunal this week, with the US tech giant now arguing that selling pre-owned Office and Windows licenses is unlawful.

    ValueLicensing says the trial will focus on whether the entire resale market for perpetual Microsoft licenses is legal, or indeed ever has been, and the result could have huge implications for Europe’s popular second-hand software market.

    The reseller contends that if Microsoft’s argument succeeds, it would mean second-hand license trading should never have existed in Europe.


    You may like

    A change of stance

    The case, which has been going on for several years now, stems from ValueLicensing’s claims that Microsoft restricted the availability of pre-owned licenses.

    According to the reseller, Microsoft offered customers discounts on subscription services if they surrendered their perpetual licenses, limiting the stock available to firms like ValueLicensing.

    It also alleges Microsoft inserted contract clauses that curtailed resale rights in exchange for further price cuts. This strategy, ValueLicensing claims, cost it £270 million in lost profits.

    Microsoft’s defense rests on the claim that it owns copyright not just to program code, but also to elements such as the graphical user interface.

    Sign up to the TechRadar Pro newsletter to get all the top news, opinion, features and guidance your business needs to succeed!

    The tech giant says the European Software Directive does not apply to such components, meaning resale is not allowed.

    ValueLicensing boss Jonathan Horley said Microsoft’s position had shifted dramatically, from denying anti-competitive conduct to arguing that the resale market itself should not exist. “It’s a remarkable coincidence that their defense against ValueLicensing has changed so dramatically from being a defense of ‘we didn’t do it’ to a defense of ‘the market should never have existed,'” he said.

    Microsoft’s stance draws on a precedent from the Tom Kabinet ruling, which found that software resale was allowed but that e-books were different.

    Microsoft is seeking to place its own products outside the rules that allowed secondary trading by making the interface distinct from software code.

    The tribunal’s decision could determine whether Europe’s thriving trade in pre-owned software survives or vanishes entirely.

    Via The Register

    You might also like

    case hand hears license Microsoft office trading Tribunal unlawful Windows
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Telegram Email Copy Link
    Previous ArticleScenes From Charlie Kirk’s Spontaneous Memorial in Utah
    Next Article MSI’s new $999 gaming laptop beats the Razer Blade 14 in a few ways (with one concern)
    Michael Comaous
    • Website

    Michael Comaous is a dedicated professional with a passion for technology, innovation, and creative problem-solving. Over the years, he has built experience across multiple industries, combining strategic thinking with hands-on expertise to deliver meaningful results. Michael is known for his curiosity, attention to detail, and ability to explain complex topics in a clear and approachable way. Whether he’s working on new projects, writing, or collaborating with others, he brings energy and a forward-thinking mindset to everything he does.

    Related Posts

    2 Mins Read

    Apple shifts from cheaper Vision Pro to accelerate AI smart glasses

    4 Mins Read

    The Ongoing Measles Outbreak Has Reached a New Peak

    4 Mins Read

    T-Mobile’s Starlink satellite service just got a huge app upgrade – adding WhatsApp, Maps, and more

    3 Mins Read

    China Rolls Out Its First Talent Visa as the US Retreats on H-1Bs

    2 Mins Read

    Tesla reverses sales decline in Q3, sells 50k more cars than it built

    4 Mins Read

    Oneleet raises $33M to shake up the world of security compliance

    Top Posts

    8BitDo Pro 3 review: better specs, more customization, minor faults

    August 8, 202533 Views

    What founders need to know before choosing their exit at Disrupt 2025

    August 8, 202520 Views

    Grok rolls out AI video creator for X with bonus “spicy” mode

    August 7, 202516 Views
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest tech news from FooBar about tech, design and biz.

    Most Popular

    8BitDo Pro 3 review: better specs, more customization, minor faults

    August 8, 202533 Views

    What founders need to know before choosing their exit at Disrupt 2025

    August 8, 202520 Views

    Grok rolls out AI video creator for X with bonus “spicy” mode

    August 7, 202516 Views
    Our Picks

    Primatologist Jane Goodall, 91, dies during U.S. tour

    October 2, 2025

    Apple shifts from cheaper Vision Pro to accelerate AI smart glasses

    October 2, 2025

    U.S. Congress deadlocked as shutdown begins; 750,000 workers face furloughs

    October 2, 2025

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest Threads
    • About Us
    • Contact us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Disclaimer
    • Terms and Conditions
    © 2025 geekblog. Designed by Pro.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.